HomeGardner2 Family - 2 Units Up/Down158 Oak Street, Gardner MA 01440
158 Oak Street, Gardner MA 01440 — photo 1 of 131 / 13
$399,900
158 Oak Street, Gardner MA 01440
2 units · 4 bd · 2 ba · 1,728 sqft · $199,950/unit
📊 Analyze this deal

INVESTMENT SNAPSHOT

Signal Score87 / 100
Est. Cap Rate5.1%
GRM12.8
Gross Scheduled Income$31,193/yr
Estimates from area median rents — directional, not an appraisal.

About this property

Versatile 2-family home currently used as a spacious single-family residence, offering incredible flexibility for investors or extended living. To be fully utilized as a 2-family, a second egress may be required. The first floor features an eat-in kitchen with abundant cabinet space and storage, a formal dining room, comfortable living room, one bedroom, and a full bath. The second floor includes its own eat-in kitchen—also ample cabinetry—three bedrooms, and a full bath. Each level boasts a private attached enclosed porch, perfect for relaxing or additional storage. This home is conveniently located near area schools, restaurants, and major routes, making commuting and daily errands a breeze. Enjoy close proximity to Mount Wachusett Community College (MWCC) as well as Dunn Park, offering convenient access to higher education, recreation, and outdoor activities. A new roof was installed in August 2024. Seller in process of clearing title issue, some flexibility in closing date required

Property details

Units2
Living area1,728 sqft
Lot size0 sqft
Year built1900
Price / sqft$231
CountyWorcester
MLS #73478636

Listing status

Days on market15 days
Listed onFebruary 19, 2026

Taxes & financials

Annual property tax$4,094
Tax year2025
Assessed value$285,100
Zoningres
Total actual rent$0/mo

Building & lot

Stories2
Total rooms8
Lot size0 acres
Garage spaces0
Parking spaces4
ParkingOff Street
BasementWalk-Out Access
FoundationStone, Brick/Mortar
RoofShingle
ConstructionFrame
FlooringTile, Vinyl, Carpet

Utilities & systems

HeatingSteam, Oil
SewerPublic Sewer
WaterPublic
Utilitiesfor Electric Range
AppliancesOven, Range, Refrigerator, Freezer

Location

More about investing in Gardner

Listing courtesy of Foster-Healey Real Estate — Wendy Poudrette. Listing data © MLS PIN.

Interested in this one?

By submitting you agree to be contacted about your home search. No spam.

Questions & answers

Auto-generated from the listing data — richer AI answers coming with the live site.

How many units does 158 Oak Street, Gardner MA 01440 have?

It is a 2-unit multi-family property with 1,728 sqft of living area, built in 1900.

How long has 158 Oak Street, Gardner MA 01440 been on the market?

158 Oak Street, Gardner MA 01440 has been listed for 15 days (since February 19, 2026).

What is the estimated cap rate on this 2-family in Gardner?

Based on area median rents, the estimated cap rate is about 5.1%, with a Signal Score of 87/100. These are directional estimates, not an appraisal.

What is the price per unit?

At a list price of $399,900 across 2 units, that works out to roughly $199,950 per unit.

What are the property taxes on 158 Oak Street, Gardner MA 01440?

Annual property taxes are $4,094 (2025), on an assessed value of $285,100.

What is the price per square foot?

At $399,900 for 1,728 sqft, that's about $231 per square foot.

Is there parking?

4 total parking spaces (off street).

Where is this property located?

158 Oak Street, Gardner MA 01440 is in Gardner, Worcester County, MA 01440.

Similar multi-families